Investigator Says Twanna “Tart” Blair Initially Was Considered "Victim"

Tuesday, September 29, 2009 - by Daniel Brantley

Former Cleveland Police Department Investigator Eric Hampton testified Tuesday that while he was working the case Twanna “Tart” Blair was always considered a "victim" in the Valentine’s Day murders in 1999.

However, Ms. Blair is currently standing trial in Cleveland in the case in which Cayci Higgins, Dawn Rogers and Orienthal “O.J.” Blair were murdered.

The state initially sought the death penalty against Ms. Blair, but is no longer making that request.

Maurice Johnson was sentenced on Aug. 25 to three life sentences after being found guilty in a separate trial. Michael Younger is to be tried later.

Officer Hampton, who is now a sergeant in Alabama, said he was called to investigate the case the day of the murders. When he arrived, medics were taking Ms. Blair from the scene. He said he then reviewed the scene of the crime, where the three victims were lying dead, and requested someone contact the Tennessee Bureau of Investigations (TBI) for assistance.

Later that day, Sgt. Hampton met with Ms. Blair at Erlanger Hospital to discuss her memory of the events.

Also, under his supervision, officers canvassed the area and made a list of individuals who knew the victims.

“There were countless interviews that were conducted by the team on that particular case,” Sgt. Hampton said. He said the interviews continued as long as he was with the CPD (he left in 2004), though the interviews typically led to dead-ends.

Under cross-examination, Sgt. Hampton said he was never shown evidence that Ms. Blair was in on the murders. Rather, she was considered a victim throughout the five years of Sgt. Hampton’s investigations.

According to Sgt. Hampton, Ms. Blair’s account of the murders began with a knock at the back door. She attempted to see who was knocking, but couldn’t. Suddenly, the back door was forced open, a few white males with short hair came in and Ms. Blair was tackled. The men – two, three or four of them – asked if there were drugs or weapons in the house. They proceeded to grab the other three individuals in the home. Ms. Blair was bound with wire ties and shot.

She thought she was dying, so she began to pray. She then heard multiple shots. Eventually, she made her way to the kitchen, where she retrieved a knife and was able to cut herself loose. She then used a phone to call 911, hours after the shootings.

“Twanna Blair, just because she lived, was no less a victim than O.J. Blair,” defense attorney Lee Davis of Chattanooga said. “Correct?”

“Correct.”

“Twanna Blair was no less a victim than Dawn Rogers?”

“That’s correct.”

“Twanna Blair was no less a victim than Cayci Higgins?”

“Yes, sir.”

Angelo Goldston said he knew O.J. and Twanna Blair (O.J. and Twanna were cousins) and was with both of them the night before the murders took place. He said O.J. Blair had a little “snort bag” of cocaine on him and maybe a little money.

He admitted that he had been at the Blairs’ apartment the week before the murders and had seen a small handgun sitting on a table at the apartment.

Prosecutor Richard Fischer at one point requested the witness be considered a hostile witness, a request that was overruled.

Defense attorney Davis then asked how the Blairs acted toward one another shortly before the murder. According to witness Goldston, they acted normal. He said at a party later that week, O.J. Blair got into a fight with someone in Sweetwater. He said Blair didn’t have a weapon, but someone fired shots after Blair had “gotten the best of whom he was fighting.” But he said there was no bad blood between the two Blairs.

Cleveland Police Department Sergeant Walter Mitchell said he was called to the scene of the crime on the day of the slayings.

Sgt. Mitchell said, “The call was pretty confusing. It gave several accounts of what was going on.”

He went on to explain that as he approached the building, he could hear someone screaming for help. This person later turned out to be Ms. Blair. When Sgt. Mitchell and another officer went in the building, they saw bodies on the floor. He then cleared the bottom of the apartment to ensure no one was inside the lower level until his supervisor arrived.

Sgt. Mitchell said he noticed damage to the back door, but he didn’t evaluate it closely. Rather, he and another officer were busy sealing off the scene with crime tape, while an emergency professional tended to Ms. Blair.

Officer Michael Harris, also with the Cleveland Police Department, said he also was called to the crime of the scene. He said he and another officer went to the rear door of the apartment building, while other officers went to the front door. Upon reaching the back door, Officer Harris said, “I could see the screen door was bent somewhat and the main exterior door was ajar.”

Reading from a report, attorney Davis stated that Officer Harris saw many things at the scene of the crime, including a black-handled kitchen knife in the floor, a bullet hole with blood smear and a small portable phone.

According to the report, Ms. Blair stated that she and other victims were shot three to four hours before being able to call emergency responders.

Prior to bringing the jury in, a courtroom officer had warned those in attendance, “You’re going to see hard evidence, you’re going to hear hard evidence. There can’t be any outbursts. We can’t tolerate anything that would influence this jury whatsoever.”

With that, the all-white jury from Bradley County had walked into the court to begin hearing the case.

daniel@danielkbrantley.com


611 Athletes And Spectators Treated At Ironman Event

Fourteen participants in  Sunday’s  Triathlon event were treated at Erlanger’s Downtown and East emergency rooms. Several were also hospitalized and required further treatment by medical staff.  A total of 611 athletes and spectators were treated by event medicine specialists in the medical tent at this year’s Ironman.  A majority of those individuals ... (click for more)

Woman Stabbed In Domestic Dispute Early Monday Morning

A woman was stabbed early Monday morning. Officers with the Chattanooga Police Department were called to a home in the 3200 block of Navajo Drive regarding a female suffering from wounds consistent with a stabbing. A  female victim was found outside a residence suffering from stab wounds.  The victim was transported to a local hospital by Hamilton County EMS. Her ... (click for more)

Patrol Cars Donation To Kevin Muhammad's Nation Of Islam Sets A Dangerous Precedent

Re: City Police donating two patrol cars to Kevin Muhammad's Nation of Islam: While I know it's unpopular to mention the wisdom of separation of church and state, this sets a dangerous precedent and should meet with concern from everyone who values religious and secular freedom. What's next? Southern Baptists getting old city parking scooters to patrol church parking lots ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: A Pitch Called ‘The Defector’

When Jose Fernandez was killed early Sunday morning in a boating accident, he was 24 years old yet had already lived a life much larger than almost all old men. He had spent part of a year in an unimaginably cruel Cuban prison, this when he only 14 years old and sandwiched in an inhumane cell among grown criminals. There were murders daily – in his very cell -- and nobody cared. ... (click for more)

Vols' Dobbs, Barnett Grab SEC Player of Week Honors

BIRMINGHAM, Ala. – Tennessee quarterback Joshua Dobbs is the SEC Offensive Player of the Week and end Derek Barnett the SEC Co-Defensive Player of the Week. This week's honor marks the first time this season that a Vol has earned SEC Offensive Player of the Week. Dobbs was the last UT player to win the award in Week 6 of 2015 following his performance in the Vols' ... (click for more)

Lee Women Win 5-1 At Shorter

The blistering-hot temperature and the artificial turf was not enough to slow the Lee women's soccer team as they handily defeated host Shorter University 5-1 for its fifth straight victory  on Sunday  afternoon.   Summer Lanter and Kinsey Cichowitz combined to score all five of Lee's goals. Lanter now has six goals on the year and midfielder Cichowitz ... (click for more)